The Rewind Storytelling Show

Join Justice Tilsher—bestselling novelist, story coach, and founder of Jesus Writing Month—as he helps Christian writers silence the fears of comparison, self-doubt, and the enemy's lies. If you're ready to step into your God-given calling and write the book that will change lives for Jesus, you're in the right place. Let's rewind the lies and fast-forward your faith-filled story.

Latest Episodes

New episodes drop every Friday. Scroll to catch up.

Episode 21
The Rewind Podcast - On Writing Characters Your Reader Falls In LOVE With

On Writing Characters Your Reader Falls In LOVE With

Be real — you've fallen head over heels for a fictional character before. For me? It was Elizabeth Bennet (don't judge). But here's the thing: there's a psychology behind crafting characters your readers actually fall in love with — and yes, it's biblical.

Episode 20
The Rewind Podcast - NaNoWriMo Is Dead. Now What?

NaNoWriMo Is Dead. Now What?

NaNoWriMo? It's dead. In this episode, I'm letting you in on what comes next — and it's called Jesus Writing Month. It's the biggest thing I've ever built. A writing revival for Christian storytellers who know their book is a calling, not a hobby. Let me tell you why it matters. And why I think it'll change your life.

Episode 19
The Rewind Podcast - Writing the Lost Man Storyline

Writing the Lost Man Storyline

My all-time favorite storytelling arc — the Lost Man. We're unpacking why it works using The Greatest Showman and It's a Wonderful Life — and how to write unforgettable characters with it.

Episode 18
The Rewind Podcast - You MUST Write Your Story

You MUST Write Your Story

God gave you the dream of writing for a reason. This episode is your wake-up call to stop letting fear and the enemy's lies hold you back — and start sharing the stories He put in your heart.

Episode 17
The Rewind Podcast - Pixar's Big Mistake - Knowing When to Get Off the Train

Pixar's Big Mistake - Knowing When to Get Off the Train

Pixar almost ruined their legacy before it started. This is the wild story of one decision — and why knowing when to quit might be the most creative choice you'll ever make.

Episode 16
The Rewind Podcast - Writing Every Day Is Murdering Your Creativity

Writing Every Day Is Murdering Your Creativity

You're burned out. Let's talk about why stepping away might save your story — and how rest is holy, not lazy.

Episode 15
The Rewind Podcast - Overcoming The Fear Of Publishing

Overcoming The Fear Of Publishing

For years, I was scared to publish. In this episode, I'm sharing how Jesus helped me overcome that fear — and how you can step boldly into your God-given calling too.